paymore logo
paymore logo

Your Local Electronics Store

Sell Your Magic The Gathering Cards for Cash

PayMore is your safe, convenient, and eco-friendly choice for selling your used Magic The Gathering cards for cash: real stores, real people, zero sketchy parking lots.

Background removed and adjusted image
gfngfh
image

We Are Actively Looking to Buy Magic The Gathering Cards

1] Visit a PayMore Store

Bring singles, boxes of cards, sealed product, or binders. Sorted or unsorted, we will go through it, and no appointment is needed.

2] We'll Pay You Cash

Our team reviews your cards at the counter and makes you an offer. The offer is free, and you leave with cash.

3] We'll Handle the Rest

We sort and sleeve what we buy and put it on our shelves for the next player. You skip the listing, the shipping, and the haggling.
appleicon
androidicon1
canonicon
samsungicon
googleicon
nintendoicon
sonyicon
xboxicon
playstation

The Best Place to Buy and Sell Magic The Gathering Cards

Magic The Gathering is more than 30 years old, and its oldest cards are still the ones people talk about. Value in Magic comes from the card, the set, and the finish. Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, and Revised cards sit at the top of the vintage market, and the Power Nine are the most famous of them. Many older cards are on the Reserved List, a promise from Wizards of the Coast that they will never be reprinted, which keeps supply fixed. Modern cards come in foil and etched versions, and products like Secret Lair drops and Universes Beyond sets add more to check. Commander has also made plenty of older cards and staples worth pulling out of a binder. Bring a box, a binder, or a single card you found in a drawer, and we will go through it with you.
Which Magic The Gathering cards do you accept?
We buy Magic singles, sealed product, and collections, from the oldest sets to the newest.
  • Vintage cards. Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, Revised, and other early sets, including Reserved List cards.
  • The Power Nine. Black Lotus, the Moxen, Ancestral Recall, Time Walk, and Timetwister.
  • Dual lands and staples. Original dual lands, fetch lands, shock lands, and other format staples.
  • Rares and mythics. From any set, in English or another language.
  • Foils and etched cards. Foil, etched foil, and other special finishes.
  • Commander cards. Commander staples, legends, and cards from Commander decks.
  • Special products. Secret Lair cards, promos, and Universes Beyond cards.
  • Sealed product. Booster boxes, Play Boosters, Set Boosters, Collector Boosters, bundles, and Commander decks.
  • Graded cards. PSA, BGS, and CGC slabs.
  • Binders and bulk. Binders, long boxes, and unsorted lots.
How much can I get for my Magic The Gathering cards?
The offer depends on the card, its set and print, whether it is foil, and its condition. Reserved List cards, older sets, and Commander staples tend to carry the most weight. Modern bulk adds up slowly, so the rares and mythics in a lot matter more than the commons. Bring sleeves, top loaders, and any slabs, and keep sets together. Our team reviews it all at the counter, and the in-store offer is free.
Background removed image
transaction in a PayMore with a tablet

Trade With Confidence

We Know Magic The Gathering Cards

Our team checks each card for set, finish, condition, and authenticity. Magic has many reprints of the same card, so we confirm the exact printing before we make an offer. We check corners, edges, surface, and centering, and we flag altered or counterfeit cards. You watch the review at the counter and see how each card was read. We do not grade cards ourselves, so bring slabbed cards in their original cases.

Buy. Sell. Trade. Recycle.

All Electronics Welcome

camero
remort

Get The Most For Your Trade-In

Bring everything in one visit, including any boxes, binders, and sealed product. Keep your top cards sleeved and your sealed product sealed, since both help the offer. Choose store credit over cash and the offer goes up, and the credit never expires. Your cards then go to a player who will build a deck with them.

Still Have Questions? Read our FAQs

Do you buy Reserved List and vintage Magic cards?
Yes. Alpha, Beta, Unlimited, and other early cards are welcome, played condition included. Bring them in sleeves or slabs, and we will identify the print and condition with you.
Do you buy modern and Commander cards?
Yes. We buy cards from current sets and from Commander decks. Rares, mythics, foils, and staples carry the offer, so set those aside before you visit.
How do you handle foil and etched cards?
We check the finish on each card, since a foil or etched version can price differently from the regular one. Bring them together with the regular copies and we will sort them out.
Do you buy bulk Magic cards?
Yes, for lots with enough in them to review. Commons and uncommons add up slowly, so rares, mythics, foils, and older sets carry the offer. For a large lot, call your local store ahead of time so staff can set aside the time.
Do you buy sealed Magic product?
Yes. Booster boxes, Play Boosters, Set Boosters, Collector Boosters, bundles, and Commander decks are welcome. Keep the shrink wrap on and the product in a dry place.
Do you buy non-English Magic cards?
Yes. Japanese and other non-English cards are welcome. Many price differently from English copies, so our team reviews them separately.
What about played or damaged Magic cards?
Bring them. Bends, whitening, and surface wear lower the offer, but an old or rare card in rough shape can still carry value. We say plainly what we can and cannot take.
Why sell to PayMore?
  • Real people. A trained person goes through your cards with you at the counter.
  • Cash on the spot. You leave with cash, or with store credit that never expires.
  • Quick visit. An average transaction takes about six minutes.
  • Repeat customers. Roughly 75 percent of PayMore customers come back.
What are the selling requirements?
  • You must be 18 or older.
  • Bring a valid physical state or government-issued photo ID.
Can I sell Magic: The Gathering cards that are foil?
Yes. Foil cards are checked for surface condition and set, and the offer reflects both the card's printing and its condition.
Do you buy unopened Magic: The Gathering booster boxes?
Yes. Sealed boxes and packs are checked for the seal and packaging, and sealed product is evaluated separately from loose cards.
Can I sell Magic: The Gathering cards that are damaged?
Yes. Cards with bent corners or surface wear still get evaluated, and the offer reflects how the card looks.
Do you buy Magic: The Gathering collections in bulk?
Yes. Large bulk lots can be sold in one visit. Sorting the cards by set first speeds up the check.

Phones. Tablets. Old School Gameboys.

We Buy a Wide Range of Electronics

Discover all the great tech that you can sell for cash or pick up at your friendly neighborhood PayMore. Whether you're trying to sell your old electronics or looking for a great deal on a pre-owned device, everyone walks away from PayMore with a smile on their face.