paymore logo
paymore logo

Your Local Electronics Store

Sell Your Graded Cards for Cash

PayMore is your safe, convenient, and eco-friendly choice for selling your used graded cards for cash: real stores, real people, zero sketchy parking lots.

Background removed and adjusted image
gfngfh
image

We Are Actively Looking to Buy Graded Cards

1] Visit a PayMore Store

Bring your slabs in a box, a bag, or a binder made for slabs. Each slab should show its grade and certification number, and no appointment is needed.

2] We'll Pay You Cash

Our team checks each slab and the card inside, then makes you an offer. The offer is free, and you take cash on the spot.

3] We'll Handle the Rest

We keep your slabs in their cases and shelve them for the next collector. There is nothing for you to list or ship.
appleicon
androidicon1
canonicon
samsungicon
googleicon
nintendoicon
sonyicon
xboxicon
playstation

The Best Place to Buy and Sell Graded Cards

A grade turns a card's condition into a number that buyers can read at a glance. PSA grades on a 1 to 10 scale in whole numbers, and a PSA 10 is Gem Mint. Beckett grades in half points and shows four subgrades for centering, corners, edges, and surface, with a BGS 9.5 Gem Mint, a BGS 10 Pristine, and a Black Label for four perfect subgrades. CGC also grades from 1 to 10. The same card can sell for different amounts at different grades, which is why the slab matters as much as the card. We buy graded cards from Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic The Gathering, One Piece, Lorcana, and sports, and we do not grade cards ourselves. Bring your slabs in their original cases, and our team will check each one against its certification number.
Which graded cards do you accept?
We buy professionally graded cards from any game or sport, in their original slabs.
  • PSA slabs. Grades from Authentic through Gem Mint 10.
  • BGS slabs. Beckett slabs, including 9.5 Gem Mint, 10 Pristine, and Black Label.
  • CGC slabs. CGC graded cards from any game or sport.
  • Other grading companies. Bring SGC and other slabs, and ask your local store whether they take them.
  • Graded Pokémon cards. Vintage and modern, English and Japanese.
  • Graded Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic, One Piece, and Lorcana cards. Any game with a slab.
  • Graded sports cards. Baseball, basketball, football, and other sports.
  • Rookie and vintage slabs. Rookie cards and vintage cards in any grade.
  • Several slabs at once. A few slabs or a full slab collection.
How much can I get for my graded cards?
The offer depends on the card, the grading company, the grade, and the current market for that card at that grade. A higher grade can change the number a lot, and PSA, BGS, and CGC slabs of the same card do not always price the same. Slabs with cracked or opened cases get a closer look. Bring each slab with its grade and certification number visible, along with any paperwork. The in-store offer is free.
Background removed and adjusted image
transaction in a PayMore with a tablet

Trade With Confidence

We Know Graded Cards

Our team checks each slab for the grade, the certification number, and the condition of the case. We look at the card through the case to confirm it matches the label, and we check for signs of tampering or counterfeit slabs. You see the review at the counter. We do not grade cards ourselves, so the grade on the slab is the starting point. The offer comes from the card, the grade, and the market, not from a guess.

Buy. Sell. Trade. Recycle.

All Electronics Welcome

camero
remort

Get The Most For Your Trade-In

Bring all your slabs in one visit so our team can review them together. Keep each one in its case, and bring any original paperwork or receipts. Choose store credit over cash and the offer goes up, and the credit never expires. Slabs you sell go to a collector who will keep them protected.

Still Have Questions? Read our FAQs

Which grading companies do you buy?
We buy PSA, BGS, and CGC graded cards. If you have slabs from another grading company, such as SGC, bring one in and ask your local store whether they take it.
Do I need to look up the certification number before I visit?
No. Each slab has the number printed on its label, and our team uses it to check the card. Just keep the label visible when you bring it in.
Does the grade change the offer?
Yes, a lot. The same card at a higher grade can bring a different offer, so our team reviews the grade, the grading company, and the card together.
Should I get my cards graded before I sell?
It depends on the card. Grading costs a fee and takes time, and the cards that tend to repay it are the ones with a real shot at a high grade. We do not grade cards ourselves, so if you are unsure, bring the card in raw and we will make an offer on it as it is.
Do you buy cracked or damaged slabs?
Bring them. A cracked case, a scratched label, or a dented corner on the slab can lower the offer, and a card taken out of its case is reviewed as a raw card. We say plainly what we can take.
Do you buy graded cards from every game?
Yes. That includes Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, Magic The Gathering, One Piece, Lorcana, and sports cards. Each game also has its own page with the details that matter for that game.
Do you buy more than one slab at a time?
Yes. Bring a few or a whole collection. For a large group of slabs, call your local store ahead of time so staff can set aside the time to review them properly.
How do the PSA and BGS scales differ?
PSA grades from 1 to 10 in whole numbers with one overall grade. BGS grades in half points and shows four subgrades for centering, corners, edges, and surface. A BGS 10 Pristine needs near perfect subgrades, and a Black Label needs four perfect 10s. We read each scale on its own terms.
Why sell to PayMore?
  • Real people. A trained person reviews your cards at the counter, one at a time.
  • Cash on the spot. You leave with cash, or with store credit that never expires.
  • Quick visit. An average transaction takes about six minutes.
  • Repeat customers. Roughly 75 percent of PayMore customers come back.
What are the selling requirements?
  • You must be 18 or older.
  • Bring a valid physical state or government-issued photo ID.
Do you buy PSA graded cards?
Yes. Cards graded by PSA are checked against their label, and the offer depends on the set, grade, and current demand.
Do you buy BGS or CGC graded cards?
Yes. Cards graded by other companies are checked against their label, and the offer depends on the grading company, grade, and set.
Can I sell a graded card that is still in its slab?
Yes. A card still sealed in its grading slab is checked without being removed, so keep the slab intact when you bring it in.
Do you buy graded cards from many different games?
Yes. Graded Pokémon, sports, Magic, and other trading cards are all evaluated, with the offer based on the game, set, and grade.

Phones. Tablets. Old School Gameboys.

We Buy a Wide Range of Electronics

Discover all the great tech that you can sell for cash or pick up at your friendly neighborhood PayMore. Whether you're trying to sell your old electronics or looking for a great deal on a pre-owned device, everyone walks away from PayMore with a smile on their face.