We Pay Cash for for Gift Cards! Get up to 75% of your Gift Card’s balance in Cash!

PayMore is Long Island’s place to sell gift cards for cash! Simply bring in your unwanted gift cards to a PayMore store. Our trained experts will quickly check the balance of the gift cards and offer you up to 75% of the card’s balance – in cash!

YOU GET

$10Cash!*
  • For Gift Cards with a balance of

    $25

YOU GET

50%Of the card's balance in Cash!*
  • For Gift Cards with a balance of

    $26-$100

YOU GET

60%Of the card's balance in Cash!*
  • For Gift Cards with a balance of

    $101-$299

YOU GET

75%Of the card's balance in Cash!*
  • For Gift Cards with a balance of

    $300+

We pay you more cash for gift cards with higher balances!

Example pricing only! Actual cash payouts will change based on: card brand, card type, card balance, and seasonality/promotions.

Trending Now!

Top 7: Highest percentages paid on these brands:

Home Depot  |  Best Buy  |  Walmart  |  Target  |  Walmart  | Amazon  | Vanilla Visa Pre-Paid  

Top 7:  Most popular gift cards sold to our stores:

Macy’s  |  Walmart  |  Best Buy  |  AMC Theaters |  CVS  |  Kohl’s  | Amazon  

We buy hundreds of different brands, here are a few examples:

  • American Express Gift Cards

  • AMC Theater’s – We do not buy Cards starting in 6006

  • Amazon Gift Cards (must not be redeemed)

  • Apple Retail Store Gift Cards

  • Applebee’s Gift cards – We do not buy cards over $50.00, or cards starting with “3” and no pin#s

  • Barnes’ & Noble’s Gift Cards – Cards over $200 we do not purchase.

  • Banana Republic – Merchandise credit not accepted

  • Bass Pro Shops

  • Baskin Robbins – Cards over $50 are not accepted

  • Big Lots – Cards starting with 6006 are not accepted

  • Bloomingdale’s Gift Cards & Store Credit

  • Best Buy Gift Cards

  • Bed Bath & Beyond – Merchandise Credit Not Accepted

  • BP Gas Station Gift Cards

  • Burger King Gift Cards

  • Buffalo Wild Wings Gift Cards – Cards of over $50 are not accepted

  • Costco Gift Cards

  • Cabela’s – Cards over $500 are not accepted

  • Charlotte Russe Gift Cards – Merchandise cards not accepted

  • CVS Gift Cards

  • Dunkin’ Donuts Gift Cards – Cards over $100 are not accepted

  • Darden Restaurant’s Gift Cards – Cards over $100 are not accepted

  • Dick’s Gift Cards

  • GULF Gas Station Gift Cards

  • EXPRESS Gift Cards

  • eBay Gift Cards – Cards over $500 are not accepted

  • Hess Gas Station Gift Cards

  • Home Goods Gift Cards (Return Cards NOT accepted)

  • Home Depot Gift Cards – Merchandise Credit not accepted.

  • Hollister Gift Cards

  • iHop Gift Cards

  • JCPenny Gift Cards

  • Kohl’s Gift Cards

  • Lowes Gift Cards

  • Macy’s Gift Cards & Merchandise Credit – Merchandise Cards starting with 83 are not accepted

  • MasterCard Gift Cards

  • McDonald’s Gift Cards

  • Moe’s Gift Cards

  • Modell’s Gift Cards

  • Nike Gift Cards

  • Netflix Gift Cards – Cards over $100 are not accepted.

  • Nordstrom Gift Cards – Cards over $500 are not accepted

  • Olive Garden Gift Cards – Cards over $100 are not accepted

  • Omaha Steaks Gift Cards

  • Office Max Gift Cards

  • Outback Steak House Gift Cards

  • PacSun

  • Pottery Barn

  • PF Chang’s Gift Cards

  • Red Lobster Gift Cards

  • Staples Gift Cards

  • Starbucks Gift Cards – Gift Cards over $100 are not accepted

  • StubHub Gift Cards

  • Sephora Gift Cards – Cards over $500 not accepted

  • Steve Madden Gift Cards

  • Stop N’ Shop Gift Cards

  • Sears Gift Cards

  • Subway Gift Cards – Cards over $100 not accepted.

  • Shell Gas Station Gift Cards

  • Sports Authority Gift Cards

  • Target Gift Cards

  • TGI Friday’s Gift Cards – Vouchers not accepted.

  • Tiffany & Co Gift Cards

  • Visa Debit Gift Cards

  • Visa Vanilla Gift Cards

  • Victoria’s Sercret Gift Cards

  • Walgreens Gift Cards

  • Walmart Gift Cards & Store Credit

  • Wendy’s Gift Cards

Didn’t see your gift card on the list? We may still buy it! Give us a call, or stop by.

Why Sell Your Old Gift Cards to PayMore?

  • We have a walk-in locations on Long Island and in Brooklyn, that pay cash on the spot!
  • We are professional, fair, and courteous.
  • We’re fast and the process only takes a few minutes.

Gift Card Selling Rules

  • We do not purchase merchandise credit cards from certain retailers. Other major brand company’s credit we may consider.
  • We may or may not purchase a gift card if the gift card’s pin number has been scratched and revealed. This is decided on a case by case basis.
  • You must sign a contract along with a valid photo ID guaranteeing the gift card is your property, and will remain valid.

We reserve the right to refuse any gift card at any time. Promotional coupons not valid on gift card purchases.

We Pay Cash on the Spot

Get top dollar in cash today for your new, used, and even broken devices! 

We Sell Electronics

Visit a store, or shop online with free delivery to Long Island, NY.

Trade In for Store Credit

Get credit towards new and gently pre-owned devices with warranties!

PayMore Locations

Visit a PayMore Store today and start buying, selling and trading electronics!

We buy broken Apple Products, such as iPhones, iPads, Macbooks, Mac Minis, iMacs and more. 

Do you have an old broken iPhone lying around collecting dust? Maybe you’re looking for places that buy broken macbooks near me? We pay cash for broken Apple products, we always need the parts!

We buy almost all iPhone models, carriers, and IMEI statuses. We are in need of broken iPads, Macbooks, Mac Minis, Apple Accessories and more.