Turn Your Game Collection Into Cash — Any System, Any Era
Sell Your Video Games in Pittsburgh at PayMore
Got a stack of games you've already beaten, a console you've upgraded from, or a collection that's just been sitting in storage? A Pittsburgh PayMore will buy it all. We purchase video games, consoles, controllers, and accessories across every system and generation — from retro classics to the latest releases. Our team stays current on the gaming market so you always get a fair offer based on what your games are genuinely selling for right now. From Bloomfield to Bridgeville, Mount Washington to McCandless, we help gamers all across Pittsburgh turn their collections into real spending money.
Hey Pittsburgh!
Get cash today for your old video games.
Ka-Ching
Types of Electronics We Accept at PayMore
At PayMore, no tech is too weird, too ancient, or too broken. We take phones, laptops, video games, virtually anything with a screen and buttons. Bring them to any of our Pittsburgh locations. Our tech experts will evaluate your devices using special software to ensure you get top dollar in return. And we'll pay you cash on the spot and thoroughly erase your data to protect your privacy.
Real stores, real people, zero sketchy parking lots.
Pittsburgh's safe, convenient, and eco-friendly choice for selling, trading and buying used video games.
How to Sell Your Video Games at a Pittsburgh PayMore
Bring Your Games Into the Store
Round up whatever you want to sell — loose cartridges, games in cases, full console bundles, controllers, or accessories — and head to any Pittsburgh area PayMore location. Bring a valid government-issued photo ID with you. Games with original cases and manuals typically get stronger offers, but we'll take a look at whatever you've got.
We Go Through Your Collection and Make You an Offer
Our team will assess everything you bring in. We check game titles, condition, completeness, and what each item is currently selling for in the market. We know which titles are in demand, which ones have collector value, and how to price a bundle fairly. You'll get a straightforward cash offer — no pressure, no games (pun intended).
Accept the Offer and Walk Out Paid
If our offer works for you, you get paid on the spot. No waiting around, no consignment, no hoping someone buys it online eventually. Just cash in hand before you leave the store.
Video Game Consoles We Accept
Current Generation Games PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X titles, recent Nintendo Switch releases — if it just came out or came out in the last few years, we're interested. Popular titles and franchises tend to hold strong value.
Last Generation Games PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and older Nintendo Switch games still have a healthy resale market. Don't assume last-gen means low value — many of these titles are still in demand.
Retro and Classic Games This is where things get interesting. NES, SNES, Sega Genesis, Nintendo 64, PlayStation 1 and 2, original Xbox — older games can be worth serious money to the right collector. If you've got a box of old cartridges in the attic, it's absolutely worth having us take a look.
Gaming Consoles We buy consoles across all generations and brands. Whether it's a PS5 or a Super Nintendo, bring it in and we'll tell you what it's worth.
Controllers and Accessories Extra controllers, headsets, steering wheels, fight sticks, charging docks — gaming accessories have real value and we buy those too.
Complete Sets Have a console with games, controllers, and all the cables? Complete setups in good condition typically get the best offers. The more you bring, the better.
Why Sell Your Video Games at a Pittsburgh PayMore?
We Actually Know Gaming Our team follows the gaming market closely — new releases, retro demand, collector trends. That knowledge means your offer is based on real current value, not a quick glance and a lowball number.
Retro Games Are Welcome Older doesn't mean worthless. A lot of retro titles for systems like the N64, SNES, or original PlayStation are worth more today than they were when they first came out. We know the collector market and price accordingly.
Same-Day Cash Payment Selling games online means waiting for buyers, dealing with shipping, and hoping nothing goes wrong. At a Pittsburgh PayMore, you accept our offer and get paid the same day — cash, no strings attached.
We Buy Loose and Complete Games Missing the case or manual? We'll still make you an offer. Complete-in-box copies get stronger pricing, but loose games aren't disqualified. We evaluate each item on its own merits.
Fair Pricing for Pittsburgh Sellers We price based on what games are actually moving for in the current market — not outdated price guides or arbitrary numbers. You'll always know exactly why we're offering what we're offering.
FAQs
Do you buy retro games and older consoles? Absolutely. Retro gaming is a strong market right now and we actively buy older titles and systems. N64, SNES, Sega, original PlayStation — bring it all in.
What if my game disc is scratched? Condition affects pricing, but a scratched disc doesn't automatically mean no deal. Depending on the title and how bad the damage is, there may still be solid value there. Bring it in and let us check it out.
Do you buy games without the case or manual? Yes. Loose games are worth less than complete copies, but they're still worth something. We'll make you an offer based on the title and condition of what you have.
Can I sell a full console bundle? Definitely. Console bundles — system, controllers, games, and cables — are always welcome. Having everything together usually works in your favor when we're putting together an offer.
How do you figure out what my games are worth? We look at the specific title, platform, condition, completeness, and what that item is currently selling for in the market. Rare or high-demand titles get priced accordingly.
Do you buy gaming accessories too? Yes — controllers, headsets, memory cards, cables, and other accessories all have value depending on the brand and condition.
Ready to Cash In Your Game Collection?
Whether you're clearing out a backlog, upgrading your setup, or just ready to move on from games you've already finished, a Pittsburgh PayMore is ready to make you a fair cash offer today. No listing fees, no waiting for buyers, no trips to the post office. Just bring your games in and walk out with money. Come see us — we're always buying.