logo
logo

Your Go-To Spot for Trading Pokémon Cards

Sell Your Pokémon Cards in NYC at PayMore

Have Pokémon cards taking up space in your NYC apartment? PayMore converts your card collection into real money. We purchase every kind of Pokémon card - rare holographics, vintage sets, modern cards, damaged cards, whatever you've got. Our NYC team knows Pokémon cards really well and provides fair prices based on actual card values. From Manhattan to Brooklyn, Queens to the Bronx, we help people across the five boroughs turn their Pokémon collections into spending money.

Hey New York City!

Get cash today for your Pokémon cards.

Ka-Ching!

Who knew decluttering could be so profitable? At PayMore, we'll give you cash for your old Pokémon cards, whether they're single cards or part of a collection. Who knows--you might even find the card you've been looking for at one of our stores! Trade in or sell, PayMore is your destination for Pokémon cards.
Find A PayMore in NYC

Pokémon Cards We Accept

We buy all types of Pokémon cards in any condition:

  • Base Set Cards (Charizard, Blastoise, Venusaur)
  • First Edition Cards
  • Holographic Cards
  • Japanese Pokémon Cards
  • Promotional Cards
  • Tournament Cards
  • Modern Sets (Scarlet & Violet, etc.)
  • Vintage Cards (Neo Genesis, Jungle, Fossil)
  • Energy Cards and Trainers
  • Complete Collections

Real stores, real people, zero sketchy parking lots.

New York City's safe, convenient, and eco-friendly choice for selling, trading and buying used electronics.

How to Sell Your Pokémon Cards at PayMore NYC

1

Bring Your Pokémon Cards to Our NYC Store

Gather up all your Pokémon cards and organize them if possible. Cards stored in protective sleeves, binders, or card protectors usually maintain better condition and command higher prices. Make sure to bring your government ID.

2

Expert Card Assessment and Cash Offer

Our Pokémon card specialists will examine your collection carefully, checking each card's rarity, condition, and current market demand. We know which cards collectors are actively seeking and price everything accordingly. Accept our offer and receive immediate cash payment.

3

Walk Out With Cash

No waiting periods or complicated paperwork - accept our evaluation and leave with money in your pocket right away.

K

Kelly

Google Review

“Great people, amazing products and electronics, quick service and kindness. Pretty great experience for selling and trading electronics. They have some great stuff to buy too like a rare Game Cube with gaming controllers! Too good of an experience!”

T

Tj

Google Review

"They provided excellent customer service. Clean, modern space, fair prices. I prefer using PayMore than any kiosk in a Walmart. Will use this service again in future."

V

Victoria

Google Review

The store itself is super nice and has plenty of electronics that look good as new even the game discs themselves. The service was amazing as well. As soon as we walked in we were greeted and assisted! He took time to go over our options and explained how he came up with the amount we could receive. We have been to a couple other stores but never received great service like this! Definitely recommend if regardless of if you’re wanting to buy or sell!

Loading GIF

Why Choose PayMore for Your Pokémon Cards in NYC?


Selling your Pokémon cards to PayMore in NYC provides several benefits:


  • Pokémon Card Knowledge: Our team actively buys, sells, and collects Pokémon cards, keeping current on market trends and valuable card identification.
  • NYC Community Focus: We're part of the local NYC collecting community and understand the city's unique market dynamics.
  • Current Market Pricing: We research active Pokémon card markets to ensure our offers reflect genuine card values rather than outdated price guides.
  • Immediate Payment: Accept our assessment and get paid on the spot - no delays or processing time.


FAQs


Which Pokémon cards have the highest value?

First edition Base Set cards, particularly Charizard, typically command the highest prices. Japanese exclusives, promotional cards, and tournament prizes can also be extremely valuable.


Do you buy damaged Pokémon cards?

Absolutely! Even damaged rare cards often retain significant value depending on the specific card and extent of damage.


What if I don't know which cards are valuable?

No worries! Bring your entire collection and our specialists will identify valuable cards and provide fair pricing for everything.


How do you determine Pokémon card values?

We assess card rarity, condition, age, and current collector demand to establish pricing based on active market transactions.


Ready to Sell Your Pokémon Cards? Visit Us Today!

Transform your Pokémon card collection into immediate cash at PayMore NYC. Our card specialists will evaluate your collection professionally and ensure you receive fair compensation for your cards. Visit us today and discover what your Pokémon collection is really worth!